Mindy DolleDomain Realty · Naples
(239) 851-2556
Naples, FL · single-family neighborhood

Oyster Bay homes for sale

As of October 16, 2026, 4 homes listed at $3M and up are for sale in Oyster Bay, Naples, FL, priced from $3.1M to $8M with a median asking price of $3.6M (about $1,427 per square foot).

1085 Sandpiper St, Oyster Bay
Current listing in Oyster Bay: 1085 Sandpiper St $8M · Listing courtesy of John R Wood Properties
4Active homes $3M+
$3.1M – $8MList price range
$1,427Median list $ / sq ft
14Closed sales, 12 months

Live from the MLS and refreshed through the day.

Free market snapshot

Get the Oyster Bay market report

Current prices, what is for sale and what has sold, in your inbox right now. Then Mindy's occasional updates, and you can stop them any time.

By submitting, you agree to receive the Oyster Bay market snapshot now and Mindy Dolle's market updates by email. Unsubscribe any time. No obligation. See our Privacy Policy.

$3M and up

Homes for sale in Oyster Bay

All Naples homes $3M+ →
1085 Sandpiper St, NaplesGulf access1 / 50
$7,995,000
1085 Sandpiper StOyster Bay · Naples
5 bd5.5 ba4,400 sf
Listing courtesy of John R Wood Properties
1510 Chesapeake Ave, NaplesGulf access1 / 34
$3,899,000
1510 Chesapeake AveOyster Bay · Naples
3 bd3.5 ba3,062 sf
Listing courtesy of Compass Florida LLC
1095 Sandpiper St, NaplesGulf access1 / 50
$3,295,000
1095 Sandpiper StOyster Bay · Naples
3 bd2 ba2,085 sf
Listing courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company
1420 Jewel Box Ave, NaplesGulf access1 / 28
$3,095,000
1420 Jewel Box AveOyster Bay · Naples
3 bd3 ba2,585 sf
Listing courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company
1390 Chesapeake Ave #1390, NaplesGulf access1 / 50
$1,499,000
1390 Chesapeake Ave #1390Oyster Bay · Naples
3 bd2 ba1,795 sf
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty
1400 Blue Point Ave #202, NaplesGulf access1 / 18
$779,000
1400 Blue Point Ave #202Escondido Marina · Naples
2 bd2.5 ba1,960 sf
Listing courtesy of Premier Sotheby's Int'l Realty
1435 Blue Point Ave #1435, NaplesGulf access1 / 33
$719,900
1435 Blue Point Ave #1435Oyster Bay Manor · Naples
2 bd2 ba1,111 sf
Listing courtesy of Premier Sotheby's Int'l Realty
1405 Curlew Ave #3, NaplesGulf access1 / 24
$685,000
1405 Curlew Ave #3Granada · Naples
2 bd2 ba1,100 sf
Listing courtesy of John R Wood Properties
1100 Little Neck Ct #f52, NaplesGulf access1 / 26
$649,900
1100 Little Neck Ct #f52Four Winds · Naples
2 bd2 ba1,171 sf
Listing courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company
1595 Curlew Ave #4, NaplesGulf access1 / 19
$549,000
1595 Curlew Ave #4Granada · Naples
2 bd2 ba975 sf
Listing courtesy of Compass Florida LLC
1417 Chesapeake Ave #106, NaplesGulf access1 / 34
$449,900
1417 Chesapeake Ave #106Chesapeake Manor · Naples
2 bd2 ba913 sf
Listing courtesy of Premiere Plus Realty Company
1379 Chesapeake Ave #a4, NaplesGulf access1 / 32
$425,000
1379 Chesapeake Ave #a4Casa Granada · Naples
2 bd2 ba1,080 sf
Listing courtesy of Realty One Group MVP
1575 Curlew Ave #1, NaplesGulf access1 / 24
$405,000
1575 Curlew Ave #1Granada · Naples
2 bd2 ba975 sf
Listing courtesy of Downing Frye Realty Inc.
1517 Chesapeake Ave #b3, NaplesGulf access1 / 21
$399,000
1517 Chesapeake Ave #b3Chesapeake Landings · Naples
2 bd2 ba1,080 sf
Listing courtesy of EXP Realty LLC
1195 Clam Ct #203, NaplesGulf access1 / 21
$295,000
1195 Clam Ct #203Clam Court · Naples
2 bd2 ba800 sf
Listing courtesy of Alfred Robbins Realty Group

Listings are shown courtesy of the listing brokerages. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Questions about Oyster Bay

How many homes over $3M are for sale in Oyster Bay?

4 homes priced at $3M or more are listed for sale in Oyster Bay, Naples, FL, according to the MLS as of October 16, 2026, out of 15 active listings overall. The list changes daily.

What do luxury homes cost in Oyster Bay?

Current asking prices at $3M and up run $3.1M to $8M, with a median of $3.6M or roughly $1,427 per square foot. Floor, view, finish and, for single-family homes, lot and water frontage account for most of the spread.

What kinds of homes are in Oyster Bay?

Oyster Bay is a single-family neighborhood in Naples, FL. Current listings include homes with 3 to 5 bedrooms, 2,085 sq ft to 4,400 sq ft, built 1977 to 2026.

Are homes in Oyster Bay on the water?

Of the 4 current listings, 4 are waterfront, 4 have Gulf access, 4 have a private pool, per MLS data. Water type and access vary by street and building, so confirm each home's details before relying on them.

How fast do homes sell in Oyster Bay?

14 sales closed in the past 12 months at a median of $483K, with a median of about 109 days on market and a median sale-to-list ratio of 95.3%. A small number of sales means these medians are only a guide.

Who can show me homes in Oyster Bay?

Mindy Dolle, a licensed Florida real estate sales associate with Domain Realty, can arrange showings, pull comparable sales and review association documents for homes in Oyster Bay. Call or text (239) 851-2556.

More in Naples