Mindy DolleDomain Realty · Naples
(239) 851-2556
Naples, FL · single-family neighborhood

Mustang Island homes for sale

As of October 16, 2026, 6 homes are for sale in Mustang Island, Naples, FL, priced from $900K to $1.25M with a median asking price of $1.08M (about $470 per square foot).

8722 Mustang Island Cir, Mustang Island
Current listing in Mustang Island: 8722 Mustang Island Cir $1.25M · Listing courtesy of ENGEL & VOELKERS NAPLES
6Active homes
$900K – $1.25MList price range
$470Median list $ / sq ft
10Closed sales, 12 months

Live from the MLS and refreshed through the day.

Free market snapshot

Get the Mustang Island market report

Current prices, what is for sale and what has sold, in your inbox right now. Then Mindy's occasional updates, and you can stop them any time.

By submitting, you agree to receive the Mustang Island market snapshot now and Mindy Dolle's market updates by email. Unsubscribe any time. No obligation. See our Privacy Policy.

For sale

Homes for sale in Mustang Island

All Naples homes $3M+ →
8722 Mustang Island Cir, NaplesNew today1 / 50
$1,250,000
8722 Mustang Island CirMustang Island · Naples
3 bd2.5 ba2,592 sf
Listing courtesy of ENGEL & VOELKERS NAPLES
9042 Bronco Ct, NaplesWaterfront1 / 50
$1,200,000
9042 Bronco CtMustang Island · Naples
3 bd2.5 ba2,570 sf
Listing courtesy of Redfin Corporation
8793 Mustang Island Cir, NaplesWaterfront1 / 50
$1,195,000
8793 Mustang Island CirMustang Island · Naples
3 bd3 ba2,527 sf
Listing courtesy of Premier Sotheby's Int'l Realty
8968 Morgan Ct, Naples1 / 31
$970,000
8968 Morgan CtMustang Island · Naples
3 bd2 ba2,028 sf
Listing courtesy of John R Wood Properties
9049 Bronco Ct, Naples1 / 24
$915,000
9049 Bronco CtMustang Island · Naples
3 bd2 ba2,038 sf
Listing courtesy of John R Wood Properties
8737 Mustang Island Cir, NaplesWaterfront1 / 30
$899,777
8737 Mustang Island CirMustang Island · Naples
3 bd2 ba2,220 sf
Listing courtesy of London Foster Realty

Listings are shown courtesy of the listing brokerages. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Questions about Mustang Island

How many homes over $3M are for sale in Mustang Island?

There are no homes listed at $3M or more in Mustang Island right now, and 6 active listings overall. Listings change daily.

What do luxury homes cost in Mustang Island?

Current asking prices run $900K to $1.25M, with a median of $1.08M or roughly $470 per square foot. Floor, view, finish and, for single-family homes, lot and water frontage account for most of the spread.

What kinds of homes are in Mustang Island?

Mustang Island is a single-family neighborhood in Naples, FL. Current listings include homes with 3 bedrooms, 2,028 sq ft to 2,592 sq ft, built 2004 to 2006.

Are homes in Mustang Island on the water?

Of the 6 current listings, 3 are waterfront, 4 have a private pool, per MLS data. Water type and access vary by street and building, so confirm each home's details before relying on them.

What are the association fees in Mustang Island?

Current listings report association fees of $790 per month, $119 to $750 per quarter. What a fee covers differs by building or community, so ask for the budget and the reserve and milestone-inspection documents before you buy.

How fast do homes sell in Mustang Island?

10 sales closed in the past 12 months at a median of $1.1M, with a median of about 41 days on market and a median sale-to-list ratio of 97%. A small number of sales means these medians are only a guide.

Who can show me homes in Mustang Island?

Mindy Dolle, a licensed Florida real estate sales associate with Domain Realty, can arrange showings, pull comparable sales and review association documents for homes in Mustang Island. Call or text (239) 851-2556.

More in Naples